Will lawsuit arise over cop's actions at crash scene?
STORY BY LISA ZAHNER (Week of November 12, 2026)
Editor's Note: A previous version of this article stated that the Vero Beach City Council would be reviewing pending litigation. No executive session or public meeting to review pending litigation is scheduled. We regret this error on the editing desk.
On top of many well-known challenges the newly-seated Vero Beach City Council will face after members are sworn-in on Monday, there are a dozen pending civil lawsuits against the City of Vero Beach, and yet another potential court case that could arise due to the actions of a Vero Beach police officer after serious island crash.
No lawsuit has been filed in the case, but a woman injured in the accident is reportedly being represented by attorney Patrick Grall of The Grall Law Group, who did not respond to a request for comment by press time.
The accident in question took place on March 1 at the corner of Beachland Boulevard and A1A. It involved the injured woman and St. Lucie County Sheriff's Office Deputy Tyler Horstman – who was arrested two weeks ago for DUI with serious injury in connection with the crash.
The female driver was at fault for the accident. She ran a red light and was hit by the deputy. But she woke up from a crash-induced coma with a traumatic brain injury or TBI, and the manner in which she was handled by Vero Beach police at the scene could create liability if a jury determines that a police officer's actions caused or exacerbated the 21-year-old woman's injuries.
First-on-scene that night was Vero Officer Edsen Thelisme, who arrived at 11:27 p.m., two minutes after the call was dispatched. Readers of this newspaper might remember Thelisme as one of two Vero officers made to leave a Vero Beach High School football game in August when they showed up off duty in plain clothes with their guns.
At the crash scene, with fire-rescue only moments away, Thelisme approached Horstman's pickup truck and noted he was trapped inside. He then walked up to the woman's SUV, which had collided with Horstman, removed the driver's baby from the vehicle and handed the baby off to a bystander. Next, he removed the female driver (referred to as D1 in the report), carried her to the sidewalk and laid her down.
"Upon arrival, I observed D1 seated in the front passenger seat with an infant positioned behind her back, partially beneath her lower back area," Thelisme wrote. "Due to the vehicle's damage and limited access, I reached through the front passenger window and removed the infant with assistance from a passerby. The infant appeared alert and responsive. I physically removed D1 from the vehicle through the same front passenger window and carried her onto the sidewalk due to her unconscious condition.
"Once on the sidewalk, I assessed D1 and observed she was breathing but unconscious and did not respond to a sternum rub ... I continued monitoring her condition until the arrival of Indian River County Fire Rescue, Run #2026-6189."
Back in April when Vero Beach 32963 first learned of the incident and obtained the crash report and related documents, Indian River County Assistant Fire Chief for EMS Steve Greer confirmed that Fire-Rescue arrived at the crash scene just five minutes after Thelisme
Paramedics worked on the female driver for 14 minutes, then took her to a helicopter landing zone so she could be transported to HCA Lawnwood Hospital's trauma center.
In April, Greer told Vero Beach 32963 that "crash victims should generally not be moved; this is an important safety consideration. Unless there is an immediate life-threatening hazard – such as fire or submersion – patients should remain in place until trained personnel arrive."
He continued: "Motor vehicle crashes often result in what we refer to as 'mechanism of injury,' meaning the forces involved can cause serious internal injuries that are not immediately visible. These may include spinal injuries, head trauma, or internal organ damage.
"Improper movement of a patient, particularly by untrained individuals, can worsen these injuries – especially those involving the spine or central nervous system – and potentially lead to permanent disability," Greer said.
It's unclear if Thelisme had first secured the perimeter so no other vehicles would drive into the sizable crash area, which was strewn with debris. There is no mention of establishing a perimeter in Thelisme's report.
"Vehicle debris and fluid consistent with a traffic collision were observed scattered throughout the roadway in the area of impact," he wrote in his report. "Exposed electrical wiring from the damaged pedestrian signal was also visible on the southeast corner of the intersection."
The second officer to arrive on scene, K-9 Officer James Doty, engaged with Deputy Horstman, who was trapped in his pickup truck, awake and talking. Firefighters later extricated Horstman and transported him by ambulance to HCA Lawnwood.
Two other Vero Beach police, Officer Kyle Keuhn and Cpl. Oscar Dominguez, wrote in their supplemental reports that they secured the scene when they arrived some minutes after the collision. Keuhn used his vehicle to block off southbound A1A, which is standard procedure to make sure another car does not compound the crash, while Dominguez assisted in securing the scene and took photographs.
Had Thelisme allowed trained Fire-Rescue crews to properly remove the 21-year-old woman and her baby from their SUV, the woman would likely have no reason to sue the City of Vero Beach. The crash investigation determined she ran a red light into the intersection where her vehicle collided with Horstman, who was found to have more than three times the legal limit of alcohol in his system when tested at HCA Lawnwood Hospital.
Beyond calling attention to the judgment of one Vero Beach Police Officer, the incident raises the question of crash response training at the Vero Beach Police Department and whether officers need a refresher – perhaps taught by firefighters and paramedics who routinely respond to multi-casualty incidents.


